Cullen's first book combines an element of fantasy with the popularity goals of a seventh-grader. Eleanor, newly transferred to Sagamore School after "moving across town," wants desperately to befriend Misty, the school's undisputed princess. But gaining entry into her clique proves challenging, especially since Misty's best friend dislikes Eleanor. Charlie, a serious, intelligent classmate, feels otherwise, but given his negligible social clout, Eleanor shuns his overtures. Yet by telling her about Joseph, an imaginary though seemingly real 12-year-old Civil War ghost, Charlie helps Eleanor win two sincere and very real friends. The novel's popularity-at-any-price theme is hardly new, and revelations about the insensitive, insecure "in crowd" have become a cliche in young people's fiction. Yet the story's main flaw lies in its self-centered, conniving protagonist; garnering sympathy for her is difficult. Snarly to her family and the loyal Charlie, Eleanor has the same wimpish quality she despises in others. The conclusion is skillfully handled, however, and almost compensates for Eleanor's slow transformation. Ages 9-12.
Copyright 1993 Reed Business Information, Inc. --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
From School Library Journal
Grade 3-6-- Moving to a new school as she begins seventh grade has left Eleanor feeling lonely and unpopular. Despite her efforts to join the in-crowd, she makes friends only with other outsiders. Desperate to attract the attention of the popular girls, she holds a Halloween party to show off the ghost of a young Civil War soldier who haunts her backyard. The mix of contemporary problems, school humor, and suspense makes a story that will be popular with readers who enjoyed Betty Ren Wright's Christina's Ghost (Holiday, 1985). The characters are interesting and multifaceted, particularly Rachel, the first in-crowder to befriend Eleanor. The wrap-up is a bit too neat, but Cullen otherwise provides a satisfying package. --Jeanette Larson, Texas State Library, Austin
Copyright 1993 Reed Business Information, Inc. --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
See all Editorial Reviews